Recreation Park I
Location: Elmira, NYUsed by: Elmira, Elmira Gladiators, Oswego Grays/Elmira Pioneers, Elmira Pioneers, Gloversville-Johnstown Jags/Elmira Rams, Elmira Colonials, Elmira Colonels
Following are the minor league baseball teams known to have played at Recreation Park I:
| Year | Team | League | W | L | Attend | Avg. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1917 | Elmira Colonels | New York State League | 62 | 54 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1916 | Elmira Colonels | New York State League | 59 | 75 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1915 | Elmira Colonels | New York State League | 72 | 53 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1914 | Elmira Pioneers | New York State League | 90 | 48 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1913 | Elmira Colonels | New York State League | 56 | 85 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1912 | Elmira Colonels | New York State League | 75 | 58 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1911 | Elmira Colonels | New York State League | 74 | 62 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1910 | Elmira Colonials | New York State League | 76 | 57 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1909 | Elmira Pioneers | New York State League | 68 | 68 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1908 | Gloversville-Johnstown Jags/Elmira Rams | New York State League | 36 | 104 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1900 | Oswego Grays/Elmira Pioneers | New York State League | 31 | 72 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1900 | Elmira Pioneers | Atlantic League | 11 | 19 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1892 | Elmira Gladiators | Eastern League | 33 | 27 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1891 | Elmira Gladiators | New York-Pennsylvania League | 47 | 49 | Roster | Stats | ||
| 1889 | Elmira | New York State League | 30 | 21 | Roster | Stats |
Attendance listed indicates the total home attendance for the team even if it played in multiple home ballparks or additional cities in the same year.
Average attendance is based on half the team's total games being played at home.
